How does this gung-ho Hollywood film tackle questions of war, feminity and masculinity? Cazz Blase reports. Directed by Wolfgang Peterson (2004).
War in Iraq, war in Israel, war in Afganistan… and war on the screen in
Wolfgang Peterson’s Troy. Hollywood reputedly spent one hundred million
dollars on Peterson’s film, and the timing of its release is interesting,
given the above mentioned conflicts. Are cinema goers to be barraged by a
gung ho, action hero, boys own war story designed to buoy up flagging
support for the war in Iraq? No, they are not. On the contrary, Troy is
more M*A*S*H or Oh What A Lovely War! than Saving Private Ryan in sentiment.
Troy can be seen to be highlighting the ultimately pointless nature of
As Odysseus (Sean Bean) sagely remarks to Achilles (Brad Pitt) “War is young
men dying and old men talking. Ignore the politics.”
That Troy can be seen to be highlighting the ultimately pointless nature of
war is probably down to the film’s source material. The film was inspired
by Homer’s ancient, epic poem the Iliad (altough it also features nods to
the Odyssey and the Aeniad) which detailed the last few weeks of the ten
year long Greek/Trojan war. The influence of Homer’s poem on the film can
also be heard in the lyrical quality of many of the speeches. The mythical
story of Troy, passed down and retold in various literary forms since
Homer’s day, runs something like this: Over 3,000 years ago the armies of
Greece led an extensive attack on the walled kingdom of Troy after Paris, a
prince of Troy, stole Helen, queen of Sparta, from her husband Menelaus.
After years of slaughter and seeming stalemate, Odysseus, the king of
Ithica, known for his cunning, hit on the idea of presenting the Trojans
with an enormous wooden horse as a gift in order to gain entry into the
city. Once inside, the Greek soldiers poured out of the horse, sacked Troy,
and burned it to the ground, carrying off plenty of wealth and numerous
Trojan women in the process. The women were raped and/or sold into slavery,
and/or murdered, whilst most of the heroes died at Troy or – in Odysseus’
case – spent a further ten years trying to go home.
Troy the film throws up a number of questions, not just concerning war, but
also notions of femininity and masculinity. Whilst Menaleus, the slighted
Spartan king, is presented as violently misogynistic, his brother Aggamenmon
is presented as greedy and mercenary: a man who wishes to conquer the world,
who is only too keen to use the slur on Menaleus’ honour to start another
war. Helen, played by Diane Kruger, is played according to Homer’s
descriptions of her. Her beauty is her dominant characteristic and –
unfortunately – it overshadows all else about her. Helen (if she ever
existed) was “the face that launched a thousand ships” and “the most
beautiful woman on earth” and, in Peterson’s film, she is given mainly to
looking vulnerable and worried, as is Hector’s (the other prince of Troy)
wife, Andromache. Andromache is shown mainly with her child, worrying about
whether Hector (who, in this version, is a nice enough bloke as well as a
good fighter) will come back from the fighting today or not, and how she and
her son will cope if he doesn’t.
Helen’s beauty is her dominant characteristic and it overshadows all else about her
Helen gets more lines than Andromache, but
her powerlessness, her status as a trophy wife, to be faught over by Paris
and Menaleus is, as ever, never entirely subdued. Orlando Bloom as Paris,
however, plays him as a young man more capable as a lover than a fighter.
He challenges Menalaus to a duel, and is quickly beaten to the ground by the
older man, where he cowers and clings to his brother’s leg as Menaleus
taunts him about his perceived lack of manhood. Until Hector puts Menaleus
out of his misery that is. Hector (Eric Bana) too is portrayed as a family
man, not just a warrior, and – on the Greek side – Brad Pitt as Achilles and
Sean Bean as Odysseus play men who know war is stupid, that our leaders are
foolish, greedy men, and – most importantly – who aren’t callous brutes.
Odysseus, we learn, is in Troy because, as a king of a small kingdom, he
cannot afford to offend the mighty Aggamenmon for political reasons.
Consequently he seeks to resolve things as quickly and as bloodlessly as
possible so that he can go home. Achilles, meanwhile, as the subject of a
prophecy that damns him to choose between a long, happy but uneventful life
of anonymity or a short life leading to eternal glory, has chosen the latter
path. He is “the greatest warrior” and, as Brad Pitt plays him, he is
arrogant yet weary and fatalistic. When he returns from a long days
fighting to find Briseus (Rose Byrne) tied up in his tent, having been
presented to him by the men as a trophy of their successful attack on the
Trojan temple to Appollo, he talks to her rather than raping her, and when
that fails, he leaves her alone to calm down a bit before having another
attempt at conversation and cleaning her wounds.
Briseus, the virgin temple priestess, represents the more spirited female
characters created by Homer, and his contemporaries. She appears to be an
amalganation of Homer’s character of the same name, and Cassandra, princess
of Troy (sister to Paris and Hector), who has also been written of as a
priestess of Appollo. Cassandra is most known for her abilities as a
prophet, and the curse placed on her by Appollo that – whilst predicting
distant events with accuracy, she would never be believed. Cassandra’s
story, or various re-interpretations of it, has been taken up in recent
years by writers, such as Marion Zimmer Bradley and Theresa Tomlinson, who
have sought to write more female centred versions of the Troy story.
Peterson’s Briseus doesn’t prophecise, she does fight back, firstly against
Achilles, then against his men when Aggamenmon removes her from Achilles
protection and hands her over to Achilles men to be raped. Briseus could be
seen to represent the sole strong female character in Peterson’s film, and
that is a shame because various early versions, and more recent versions of
Troy tell of at least one Amazon warrior who faught at Troy. As regards the
female characters included in Peterson’s film, whilst we know that Helen
chooses willingly to go to Troy, and whilst we see Briseus fight back
against her captors and challenge Achilles’ decisions, it is a pity so
little is made of Andromache as a character. So much has been done to
convey Achilles, Odysseus, Paris, Hector, and King Priam (played here by
Peter O’Toole) as men who are both strong and vulnerable, lovers and
fighters, sensitive and murderous.
On the other hand, having been subjected to trailers for the re-make of The
Stepford Wives and for a rather aggressive piece of fluff entitled Thirteen
Going On Thirty prior to Troy, I would summise that gender relations in
Trojan times, whilst delivered via Hollywood, come off as looking a good
deal healthier than in contemporary themed Hollywood films.