The mantra of "choice" and why it is bad news for girls and boys

The Independent runs with an interesting story today, about what girls and boys want to learn in science class.

Leeds University asked a bunch of 15 year olds what they were interested in being taught. Perhaps unsurprisingly, given our cultural climate:

Boys like …

* Explosive chemicals.

* How it feels to be weightless in space.

* How the atom bomb functions.

* Biological and chemical weapons and what they do to the human body.

* Black holes and other spectacular objects in outer space.

* How meteors, comets or asteroids can cause disasters on earth.

* The possibility of life outside earth.

* How computers work.

* The effects of strong electric shocks and lightning on the human body.

* Brutal, dangerous and threatening animals.

Girls like …

* Why we dream and what it means.

* Cancer, what we know and how can we treat it.

* How to perform first aid and use basic medical equipment.

* How to exercise to keep the body fit.

* How we can protect ourselves against sexually transmitted diseases.

* What we know about HIV/Aids and how to control it.

* Life and death and the human soul.

* Biological and human aspects of abortion.

* Eating disorders such as anorexia and bulimia.

* How alcohol might affect the body.

This can be summed up as: boys are interested in explosions, death, space and technology; girls are interested in their bodies and medicine.

To me, there is something a little melancholy about the preferences of these 15 year olds. Is the lesson that girls are so obsessed with body image that they don’t have room for an interest in what it feels like to be weightless in space?

But it is also revealing that this is rooted in their own lives: how to deal with sex, how to deal with drink, the prospect of cancer. Are the 15 year old boys honestly seeing themselves as astronauts? Perhaps not, but the suggestion of these Leeds researchers, that the Government should introduce a seperate curriculum for each of the sexes, would mean that only boys would have a chance of becoming one.

Oh, and none of them would know anything about STDs. Great idea, guys!

This is just another example of where too much choice, too early, is a bad thing. Teenagers might be breaking away from the authority of their parents, but they find refuge in conformism. They are little barometres of social mores. As this poll reveals, I would say.

The answer isn’t to cater for them, allow their lives to be shaped by a brief period of dizzy social monoculture, but to force them to try everything so they can make true, non-conformist choices later on if they want to.

Posted by Jess McCabe on 13 March 2006, at 8:22 AM

< back | top ^ | next >

Latest Posts
The Sun and its slideshow of "ugly" sex workers
Take Back the Tech?
Hillary Clinton appointed US Secretary of State
Some articles of interest
Comments for October
Book Club Choice #2: Noughts And Crosses
Feminism, Disability & Activism Zine: call for submissions
16 Days Against Violence Against Women
Not a slow blogging round-up
More posts
Latest Comments
Jess McCabe on The Sun and its slideshow of "ugly" sex workers
Paulette on The Sun and its slideshow of "ugly" sex workers
Laura Woodhouse on Female artist's belly too fat for record label
Jess McCabe on The Sun and its slideshow of "ugly" sex workers
Sabre on The Sun and its slideshow of "ugly" sex workers
Paulette on The Sun and its slideshow of "ugly" sex workers
Maia on The Sun and its slideshow of "ugly" sex workers
Raiven on Female artist's belly too fat for record label
Fran on The Sun and its slideshow of "ugly" sex workers
Kez on The Sun and its slideshow of "ugly" sex workers
More feminist bloggers
There are plenty of fantastic UK feminist bloggers around. For a fantastic introduction to feminist blogging, go to the Carnival of Feminists website, which showcases the finest feminist posts from around the blogsphere, including many from UK blogs.
Small Print
All blog posts are the views of the individual post author, and not those of The F-Word.

Inside this section

Blog Home
Archives by Month
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
More Archives
Archives by Author
Abby O'Reilly
Anne Onne
Barbara Felix
Carrie Dunn
Catherine Redfern
Guest Blogger
Helen G
Holly Combe
Jess McCabe
Kate Smurthwaite
Laura Woodhouse
Louise Livesey
Lynne Miles
Milly Shaw
Samara Ginsberg
Sokari Ekine
Yvonne Howard
zohra moosa
News prior to April 2005
XML feed Feeds
Latest Blog Posts
Latest Comments

Contact Us

This webpage lives at: http://www.thefword.org.uk/blog/2006/03/the_mantra_of_c