Mini review: She Should Have Gone to the Moon

by Jess McCabe // 17 August 2009, 21:06

astronaut.jpgShe Should Have Gone to the Moon is a documentary about Jerri Truhill, one of 13 women who trained to go into orbit in the early years of the US' space programme, but who never made it because of sexism in Nasa and the US government.

The story itself is fantastically interesting: Truhill was breaking boundaries just be training to be a pilot. She explains how she did what was expected of a woman from her background at the time, get married quick and have two kids, then trained to be a commercial pilot. There are some charming moments when she explains how as a girl, her mum would painstakingly put her hair into Shirley Temple curls, then as soon as she was out of sight she'd jam a pilot's helmet and goggles over the top.

Once she was working as a pilot, Jerri started doing top-secret missions for the US government, before becoming one of 60 female pilots invited to try out to become an astronaut.

Truhill explains how the women who passed the initial tests became the 'Mercury 13', put through a rigerous programme and stretched to physical extremes. This was in the early 1960s, all before any US citizen had been into space, so, she explains, the scientists were testing for everything. For example, they got the pilots to drink radioactive water and wait to see how long it took to go through their system.

The female pilots passed some tests better than the male astronauts-in-training, she says - for example, the men only lasted a short time in the sensory deprevation tanks before demanding to get out; the women pilots lasted hours and hours, until the scientists came to get them. Maybe some of this was to do with the extra pressure and knowledge that they had to prove themselves physically capable. The scientists said that they were better suited than men to go into space, and some thought they would be the first to go because they were smaller than the male astronauts and needed smaller life support systems. It was not to be, as politicians and Nasa quashed the notion and went for male-only astronauts.

However, the documentary, directed by Ulrike Kubatta, can seem a bit spare at times. It seems to have been based largely on one phone interview and one in-person interview, and we don't get to see much in the way of photos, footage from the time, etc. There are long sequences of someone dressed as Truhill walking in a lunar-like desert landscape, for example. I am guessing it was hard for Kubatta to find source materials she could use, and it's good to see Truhill's particular story being told, but this was a weakness.

It'd have been interesting to include interviews with some of the other women, perhaps, and look at the situation in the USSR at the time - Valentina Tereshkova became the first woman in space in 1963, the year after the Mercury 13 were rejected by Nasa - 20 years before the US eventually managed to send Sally Ride up as the first US woman in space. Mae Jemison became the first African American woman in space in 1992. Helen Sharman was the first Briton in space, but also the first non-US, non-USSR woman in space, in 1991.

There's some interesting discussion of how pleased Truhill and the others were when Eileen Collins became the first woman to pilot the shuttle (because they were pilots, this held special significance for them). But it could have done with a bit more placing the story of the Mercury 13 within the global picture and in history.

(You can see the trailer on the IMDB)

Comments From You

Hazel // Posted 17 August 2009 at 22:57

There is a radio documentary from 1997 available on the BBC Archive which tackles the same subject. It's called "Right Stuff, Wrong Sex" and has contributions from Jerrie Cobb, Wally Funk, and others.

It was fascinating.

Aimee // Posted 18 August 2009 at 12:41

Things like this make me so sad. Just thinking about all the great opportunities that women have missed out on because of sexism. I was having an argument with my boyfriend's friend the other day about how there were 'no awesome women guitarists', and it's kind of the same thing, because there are women guitarists, really good ones, but they're probably not 'hot' enough, or willing to take their clothes off, or maybe they;re just never taken seriously. This is kind of the same thing.. there are women astronauts, women race car drivers, women engineers, fantastic women scientists... they are just not given the same opportunities as men. It's so sad. And such a waste. What a pointlessly wasteful and stupid thing sexism is.

Soirore // Posted 18 August 2009 at 13:23

You're into documentaries at the moment, huh Jess? Are there any other women-focused film documentaries that you'd particularly recommend?

Jess McCabe // Posted 18 August 2009 at 14:53

@Soirore Yep, I'm at home sick :-) I also watched the BBC's depressing 'Trouble With Girls' series the other day, which is on iplayer, but I'm not sure recommend is really the word for it...


R // Posted 19 August 2009 at 14:48

Augh, get better soon Jess!

As another documentary fiend, keep these coming- I'm going to badger the local fleapit to host some of these :)

Have Your say

Latest Comments

Reclaiming The F-Word

Founder of The F-Word, Catherine Redfern, has co-authored a new book with Kristin Aune. Find out more at the Reclaiming The F-Word website.

Further Reading

Has The F-Word whet your appetite? Check out our Resources section, for listings of feminist blogs, campaigns, feminist networks in the UK, mailing lists, international and national websites and charities of interest.

Write for us!

Got something to say? Something to review? News to discuss? Well we want to hear from you! Click here for more info

  • The F-Word Feeds
  • #
  • #