Science: it's always been a girl thing

by Guest Blogger // 8 November 2012, 22:40

Tags: career, gender stereotyping, science, sexism, work

This is a guest post by Luzia Troebinger, a PhD student living in London.

Earlier this year, the European Commission produced a commercial intended to make careers in science more appealing to women. Originally appearing in connection with the 'Science -It's a Girl Thing' campaign, the video (see below) was downright offensive and prompted numerous enquiries as to whether it had been an attempt at irony (it wasn't). The only positive thing that can be said about it is that it disappeared rather quickly.

The film features a serious man in a lab coat, sitting in front of a microscope. In come the 'girl scientists', in very short skirts and very high stilettos. Serious man scientist stops his serious scientific efforts to stare at them in a very disturbing way. Silly girl scientists being their silly selves giggle, drop stuff all over the place and experiment with lipsticks and other cosmetics.

Aside from all the obvious things wrong with this, there is a more subtle point here: the assumption that the problem is women not being interested in science.

I don't believe this is true.

Women do find science interesting. Women love technology. And we are every bit as capable of studying science and engineering as men are.

The problem lies elsewhere. Women are often deterred from pursuing a career in science or engineering because of the 'boy's club' atmosphere encountered in the workplace. It is the playground mentality of 'no girls allowed' that discourages a lot of us.

scientists.jpg

As an engineering student, I was often put off because lecturers would make blatantly sexist comments under the guise of 'innocent banter', which was directed at the overwhelmingly male audience and in fact served as an indication that they were either oblivious to the fact there were female students in the audience or, worse still, actually meant to cause offense.

In a seminar on computer vision, the speaker used an image of a 'woman' from a computer game as an example for a pattern recognition problem: pattern woman = breasts-buttocks-bee-stung-lips. The speaker's comments ('This is a shape that I'm sure we all recognise...', wink wink) made it even worse.

But this is only the tip of the iceberg. After graduating from university, I worked as an engineer in the R&D department of an international company. I worked there for less than a year, and it wasn't exactly a walk in the park.

My role was to program a particular type of sensor, as well as to help with any problems that occurred in the ones that were in operation on sites across the globe.

I wrote the program for the device. I pretty much took it apart and put it back together. I worked with this thing every day and wrote large parts of the manual. I pretty much WAS that sensor, and it was me.

However, a lot of male technicians who worked with it on site would still rather call a male engineer from a completely different group to ask questions - simply because they couldn't take advice from a woman.

My supervisor told me that I couldn't travel to the testing site for product tests, because I was a woman and this was 'a building site environment'. As such, he thought I could only go there if a man would accompany me.

This same person also tried to take credit for my work using the 'you-are-a-woman-and-need-me-to-represent-you' approach. I refused to be passive and complained about his behaviour to our boss - all I got was a 'mark your territory' speech from my boss, and my supervisor went out of his way to trash-talk my work and me as a person, pretending I was an incompetent, lazy snake in the grass.

To make matters worse, our company's employee representative, who was supposed to be the first point of contact in case of any such problems, was a sleaze who would leer and make inappropriate comments about my body. However, I felt that if I said something about it, I would be in an even worse position since I would lose his support - something that had happened to a female colleague of mine.

And then of course there is always the pressure of suddenly being made a representative of the entire female population - that is, if you aren't twice as good as the best of your male colleagues, this is taken as proof that women just can't do science or engineering.

So I think rather than taking the 'you-can-be-a-scientist-and-look-hot' approach, we ought to be thinking about how we can make sure that we provide an adequate, comfortable working environment. And, dear European Commission, lipsticks and lab coats have nothing to with that.

The black and white photo shows a group of male and female scientists in white lab coats in a lab holding a long, thin piece of paper that looks like a tape measure. They are members of the team of ARS and Cornell University researchers who first determined the molecular structure of RNA. Photo by mars_discovery_district, shared under a Creative Commons licence.

Comments From You

Rose // Posted 09 November 2012 at 10:47

As a physics kid I totally agree.

I love my science, but hate the abuse that flows unchecked at women in science.

IronFly // Posted 10 November 2012 at 03:52

Hi Luzia,

Im sorry you've experienced sexism in engineering. I was very lucky when I was an engineer, I very rarely experienced it - I worked offshore a bit too, the ultimate building site. Working on-site always helped me understand the theoretical stuff I did back at the office. Any company who thinks gender is so limiting that they cant send female employees to a building site is living in the dark ages. Do you still work for that company?

Lucy // Posted 13 November 2012 at 10:50

I no longer work for that company - I got offered a funded PhD position, and I always aimed to get into academic research rather than work in industry. However, this is actually a really important point - how much longer would I have been able to stand my ground at that place? Clearly, if you are feeling miserable at work, your quality of life is kind of going down the drain. But if you quit and look for a different job, another woman has successfully been forced out of a male-dominated environment, thus leaving the boys' club to the boys.
I think it's important for every woman who experiences this type of behaviour to go public about it, because this is the only hope we have of changing things.

Have Your say

Latest Comments

Further Reading

Has The F-Word whet your appetite? Check out our Resources section, for listings of feminist blogs, campaigns, feminist networks in the UK, mailing lists, international and national websites and charities of interest.

Write for us!

Got something to say? Something to review? News to discuss? Well we want to hear from you! Click here for more info

  • The F-Word Feeds
  • #
  • #