This minimally sane lunatic fights back

by Philippa Willitts // 29 January 2013, 19:14

Tags: disablism, disablist language, hate speech, mental health, misogyny, stigma

deva asylum.jpg

It is painful when somebody you respect says something hurtful, or when something you otherwise fundamentally agree with becomes offensive. Reading Laurie Penny's article today about the violent hatred directed towards women online, I was appalled at what she, Mary Beard, and others, have had directed at them. And then came the sentences that felt like a punch in the stomach:

It'd be nice to think that the rot of rank misogyny was confined to fringe sites populated by lunatics. Unfortunately, not only are men like White clearly at least minimally sane enough to hold down desk-jobs, their school of misogyny has become an everyday feature of political conversation online, particularly in the UK.
Why on earth, in an otherwise brilliant piece of insightful writing on misogynist hate, did it seem appropriate, or even fair to implicate those of us with mental health problems? What association does Laurie make between people like me (user of mental health services, taker of psychiatric pills) and people like them (vicious online haters with violent, misogynist fantasies)?

This is not a random association. This occurs again and again, all over discourse both left and right. Melissa McEwan wrote last week,

But the more distance I get from relying on disablist language--and the more I am forced to say what I really mean, that Mitt Romney (for example) is not crazy, but indecent and cruel and privileged--the more I realize how progressive pundits' reliance on disablist language is not merely hurtful or alienating, but counterproductive.
I am, arguably, a minimally sane lunatic. I fight with all my might against misogyny and women-hating, yet within two sentences of Penny's article, I am the same as the haters. And when it is so, so easy to suggest that I am like them, simply because thinking of an alternative framework for insults would be too difficult then I feel shame, I feel embarrassed, I feel hurt and I feel deeply stigmatised.

Misogyny and male violence are significant causes of women's mental health problems. Those of us affected in this way should never, ever be lumped in with those who caused it, by virtue of a diagnosis and a lazy metaphor.

Fighting misogyny with disablism is not the answer. Fighting threats of violence with disablist hate speech is not the answer. Making me feel ashamed and implicated in the misogyny I try to fight against nearly made me silent, but I could not let it go unchallenged. It hurts, it's incorrect, it's lazy and it's wrong.

[The image is a photograph of the abandoned, derelict Deva asylum in north Wales. It shows a long corridor with peeling paint and an old patient trolley. It was taken by Nick Cummins and is used under a Creative Commons Licence]

Comments From You

Laura // Posted 29 January 2013 at 22:48

I'm glad you were able to write this, Philippa. I was disappointed by this language in an otherwise well-written article on an important feminist issue, but reading how it affected you as a person really highlights the impact that the lazy use of disablist metaphors for negative behaviours and attitudes has on real people.

Quinn Capes-Ivy // Posted 30 January 2013 at 10:33

Thanks for this, Pippa. It's always hurtful when we are marginalised and insulted because of our disabilities. It's so bloody ingrained, is the problem - I find myself muttering "crazy bitch" under my breath at an erratic motorist, for example, and I am in fact a truly crazy bitch (like you, I'm a "user of mental health services, taker of psychiatric pills"). I feel like words to do with mental health problems are seen as 'normal' and 'acceptable' to use in derogatory ways, and I'm not sure how we go about changing that. But this article is a good start. Hopefully Laurie (who I really like and respect) will read this and reconsider her use of this language.

Philippa Willitts // Posted 30 January 2013 at 10:37

Anji you're right, it's because it's so ingrained that mental health-related insults seem some of the hardest to shake off.

Someone shared the article with Laurie on Twitter and she did immediately apologise and she understood why people were upset. We can all make these mistakes, I think it's often how we react when it's pointed out to us that is more important.

Quinn Capes-Ivy // Posted 30 January 2013 at 11:21

Laurie has posted a longer apology at her site.

Philippa Willitts // Posted 30 January 2013 at 11:23

You *just* beat me to posting that!

Have Your say

Latest Comments

Further Reading

Has The F-Word whet your appetite? Check out our Resources section, for listings of feminist blogs, campaigns, feminist networks in the UK, mailing lists, international and national websites and charities of interest.

Write for us!

Got something to say? Something to review? News to discuss? Well we want to hear from you! Click here for more info

  • The F-Word Feeds
  • #
  • #