Fat in film is a feminist issue

by Guest Blogger // 21 February 2014, 12:16

Tags: fatphobia, film, representation of women, TV

This is a guest post by Lily Kendall, a feminist human rights activist living in London. Lily is a founding writer for feminist blog The Hussington Post and spends her free time watching cats on YouTube.

My Mad Fat Diary has made a welcome return to our TV screens this week. Protagonist Rae Earl gives us a refreshing (and all-too-rare) female take on burgeoning teen sexuality, body image and mental health. It's encouraging to hear a young female character speak frankly and humorously about sexual desire (top quote: "I want him to go down on me for so long he has to evolve gills"). It made me consider how rare it is to see a portrayal of a larger woman on screen speaking in a genuine and human way about her sexuality.

My_Mad_Fat_Diary.jpg

The show is, in my opinion, a positive move in the right direction. My only quibble is this: why must larger women constantly be defined by their size? It's great that we are addressing the existence of damaging body issues created by the pressures of our society (something sadly not diminished since the early 1990s when show is set). But isn't it damaging that almost every time we encounter a larger woman on screen, she's obsessing about her weight?

Larger characters always seem to operate within the paradigm of a universally skinny peer group, which over-emphasises their comparative "fatness". The world doesn't operate on some bizarre binary system in which the occasional "fat" person crops up in a landscape of "skinny" people, so why does the world as represented in film and TV reflect this warped perspective?

I started thinking about the larger women we see on screen. They almost never make up bit parts. How often do we see plus-size extras? Almost everyone in film is slim by default. This thought occurred to me whilst watching the Oscar-nominated Nebraska. Plus-size character Nöel, played by Missy Doty, has only one scene and her size isn't mentioned. It suddenly struck me how unusual this is - we're so used to seeing larger women on screen only in the event that the plot requires them to be large.

From the get-go roles for women and men are cast differently, with women's roles overwhelmingly reliant on appearance. Miss L's brilliant Tumblr has been highlighting the inherent sexism of casting calls since early last year. Laura Bates of Everyday Sexism started the movement in response to sexism in the film industry. In the descriptions of character traits men are defined by what they do, by their driving ambitions, by the inner workings of their soul. A typical casting call for a female role might read "slim, nice hair, attractive". A woman has to conform to some pretty narrow criteria just to qualify for most roles. It seems that a larger woman won't even be considered for a role that doesn't specifically involve a size-based plot-line.

Why should fat be a defining characteristic? Slim characters have all sorts of story-lines, their remit within a film reaching beyond their weight. 'Fat' people are fat. They might be struggling against it (Hairspray), be comical because of it (Bridesmaids) or even grotesque and 'un-female' as a result of it (Big Momma's House). A particularly damaging stereotype is that of the large woman with the comically high libido. This points to a broader sexual standard within our society which takes a woman's sexuality seriously only to the extent that she falls within the confines of the recognisable sex object. It's for this reason that Rae's frank and funny descriptions of her own sexual escapades are so welcome - they describe her relationship with her own sexuality on her own terms.

Ordinarily the film and TV industry seem incapable of seeing a larger woman as sexually desirable, so her desires must be relegated to the realm of slapstick. Failing that, she's often rendered 'masculine' or a-sexual. In fact, larger female characters are just as likely to be played by men as women. Look at Big Momma's House, Hairspray, Jack and Jill, Norbit... I have no problem with actors gender-bending. But when larger female characters are played by skinny men for comedy, reducing the image of larger women to adolescent snigger-fodder, it's clearly problematic.

In 1978 Susie Orbach proclaimed that fat is a feminist issue. In 2014, it's clearly still something we should concern ourselves with. Fat in film is a feminist issue. It's a feminist issue because the absence of larger women on screen is most likely a direct result of the fact that films still reflect the societal male gaze. It's a feminist issue because as long as larger women only appear on screen in relation to their weight, society will continue to see size as a defining feature. As long as larger female characters are denied story-lines that extend beyond the scope of their bodies, fat in film will remain a feminist issue, and one that demands our attention.

The picture is a still promoting My Mad Fat Diary Season 2 on Channel 4 and is taken from the series official Facebook page. It depicts a group of young people on the bus.

Comments From You

The Goldfish // Posted 21 February 2014 at 13:38

This is a great piece, and I think there are many cross-overs with the portrayal of other marginalised women, perhaps especially older women (whose libidos are considered similarly comical and are - more rarely but still occasionally - played by men). There are also no shortage of movies which focuses on unfitness or physical imperfection among men (Dodgeball, Run Fat Boy Run) where all the women in sight remain thin and super fit as if that's the natural feminine state of being.

A notable exception off the top of my head are the movies of Queen Latifah. I had quite an infatuation with the woman, watched almost everything she's been in and I can tell you that some of those movies are pretty dreadful. However, often her weight is never referred to and other times it is mentioned as a positive thing, a major component of her general sexiness.

MyFeministLife // Posted 21 February 2014 at 17:36

Hello, great post so thanks for writing it. I have only seen the show a couple of times but immediately saw the benefit of it's existence, especially for teenage girls to have an alternative view to the same old stereotype of female protagonist.

I am in the process of writing a post for my own blog about how we refer to ourselves when it comes to words like 'fat' 'ugly' and 'skinny'; my main point will be that people who love us would not refer to us in these terms so perhaps we should not refer to ourselves in these ways either. It's a debate type piece from a feminist perspective. Just wanted to check if it's okay whether I cite this post in my own one? It will be in a relevant and completely complimentary way; if you want I could send you my article first for you to okay it before I publish? I am new to all of this and don't really know how it works yet! I love it when people refer to other posts in their own as it leads me to new and interesting things so it's something I wanted to do in my own one.

Thanks for taking time to read this if you did! x

Lily // Posted 27 February 2014 at 00:07

Hi both, thanks for your lovely comments, glad you liked the post.

That's a really good point - older women do seem to get similar treatment now I think about it. I fear I may now lose many hours of my life 'researching' Queen Latifah movies... :)

Definitely feel free to reference the post however you wish and link back to it, I'll be interested to read your post. Since working with children I've realised how problematic self-deprecation can be - it's so easy to apologise for ourselves or point out our own flaws all the time and I think it can be quite damaging to kids looking to us as role models (p.s love your Beyonce post!)

Have Your say

Latest Comments

Further Reading

Has The F-Word whet your appetite? Check out our Resources section, for listings of feminist blogs, campaigns, feminist networks in the UK, mailing lists, international and national websites and charities of interest.

Write for us!

Got something to say? Something to review? News to discuss? Well we want to hear from you! Click here for more info

  • The F-Word Feeds
  • #
  • #