Should Ched Evans get his job back?

by Sarah Flude // 2 May 2014, 15:09

Tags: Ched Evans, criminal justice system, rape

Ched_Evans by By Dan Goddard.jpg

As a resident of Sheffield I am beginning to hear whispers concerning the Sheffield United player and convicted rapist Ched Evans rejoining the club upon his release from prison. The city of Sheffield, sometimes split in two by its two rival football teams, is apparently divided on this subject also. There are separate petitions doing the rounds on Facebook and other social media sites both to support him returning to the club and to show opposition to the club possibly signing him again.

I also find myself torn on what should be the footballer's fate once he is released from prison. There is no doubt that he will fare better than many ex offenders after release from prison. Government figures show that 47% of offenders released from prison in 2008 were in receipt of out-of-work benefits within two years of release. Working with ex offenders myself I know first hand of the difficulties that can be faced by somebody who has served the sentence given to them and even taken steps to be rehabilitated, only to face endless obstacles when looking to rejoin and contribute to society. Often the young men that I have worked with have been disadvantaged from birth, growing up in socio-economic conditions and family structures which made doing something meaningful with their lives unlikely. In these cases is in not difficult to feel empathy and aim to help these ex offenders to maximize the life chances they have in the future.

However, in the case of Ched Evans my initial reaction was that a return to his highly paid, high profile job is somewhat of an insult; to his victim, to other rape victims and to any future victims who may feel disheartened about reporting attacks to the police. The reporting rate for sexual violence is already regrettably low and elevating convicted offenders into a role such as a professional footballer is surely sending out a message to rape victims: even if you are believed, even if your attacker is convicted, society will still welcome the rapist back with open arms once their short sentence is over.

My six-year-old son is an avid football fan, a season ticket holder at his local club and an admirer of many professional footballers. These men are his idols, he wants to emulate them and he looks up to them. How would I feel if my son was excitedly telling me he wants to be just like Ched Evans when he gets older? I feel that my duty then, as a mother, a woman, in fact as a human would be to discourage him from this.

This case highlighted to me the patriarchal world of professional football, where young men are given wealth, status and fame beyond their expectations and some appear to think this includes the right to use women as commodities also. Ched Evans still claims to be innocent and, after reading his website, it seems he has little regret about the events that took place that night - apart from that it resulted in a conviction. Even if the victim had consented, which a court of law ruled that she could not have, the act of having sex with a young girl so drunk she could hardly stand minutes after his friend had also had sex with her apparently presents no problem to this young man. Perhaps more worryingly, his girlfriend, family and a large number of football supporters have also accepted this behavior. As long as this remains a common attitude in society it is difficult to see progress being made. Many people have presented the victim in this case as the wrongdoing party, because of alleged tweets she made after the attack, and they paint Ched Evans as a man who has been wronged.

All these things considered, the fact still remains that Ched Evans will be released from prison this year and will continue to live his life, whether that be as a professional footballer or not. As unpalatable as it may seem, the alternatives to him returning to his former profession would be that he remains in prison, is prevented from working at all, or forced to take another form of employment against his will. This may not seem unthinkable when dealing with such a heinous crime as rape, but in reality none of these options are a viable possibility. Being able to rejoin society after imprisonment is a must for a civilized society. There will always be cases, such as this one, where this sits uncomfortably with a proportion of the public, but I believe that when looking at the bigger picture it is a value that must be upheld.

[The image is a photograph of Ched Evans, a white male footballer wearing a red shirt with the number 10 on it. It was taken by Dan Goddard and is in the Public Domain]

Comments From You

Laura // Posted 02 May 2014 at 17:28

Hi Sarah,

I really have to disagree with you very strongly here. You say: "As unpalatable as it may seem, the alternatives to him returning to his former profession would be that he remains in prison, is prevented from working at all, or forced to take another form of employment against his will" and that none of these options are "a viable possibility". Why is it not viable for him to take up another form of employment? Why should he continue to enjoy the public profile and adulation granted footballers when his victim has had her world turned upside down, not just by the rape, but by the harassment that followed, which resulted in her having to change her name and move home? No one is guaranteed continual employment in the same job or field - it's very normal for people to have to change jobs due to life circumstances. Evans chose to rape a woman: he should not expect to just be able to return to the life he had before he did this.

Furthermore, Sheffield United do not need to sign Evans: they can choose not to and leave it up to other clubs to decide whether they want to take him on. As a Sheffielder, I do not want my city represented by a rapist. I do not want rape survivors in my city to have to see his face and name plastered across local newspapers.

I have absolutely no problem with rapists being stigmatised. One of the reasons why so many get away with rape is because there is actually little stigma attached to being a rapist (just look at how many people jumped to Evans' defence): the stigma is heaped on the victim instead. Personally, the last thing I'm interested in doing as a feminist is upholding rapists' employment rights, let alone rapists previously employed as footballers.

The petition against his reinstatement can be found here.

Elisa // Posted 03 May 2014 at 00:06

Agree wholeheartedly with Laura, as usual!

steve // Posted 03 May 2014 at 11:21

If Ched Evans was a bricklayer or plasterer, then no-one would care what he did when he came out of prison but him being a footballer seems to make a difference to some people.
He has served his sentence so should be allowed to resume his life as is the nature of our democratic rights.
So the problem with most that oppose him returning to football and Sheffield United seems to be the money he will earn. Ched Evans is probably very wealthy anyway, so it really should not be an issue. Rape is an awful crime and no-one disputes that but that doesn't mean he should be persecuted for the rest of his life. Everyone deserves a second chance.

Elisa // Posted 03 May 2014 at 13:56

The problem is with him being a public figure respected and emulated by impressionable young people. The problem is with his continued success being public knowledge, available to the survivor of his crime while she lives with the likely life-long trauma of it. The problem is with the attitude that any kind of atonement has happened for that crime, or could happen, especially in the absence of any repentance on his part. It's not 'all in the past now'.

Have Your say

Latest Comments

Further Reading

Has The F-Word whet your appetite? Check out our Resources section, for listings of feminist blogs, campaigns, feminist networks in the UK, mailing lists, international and national websites and charities of interest.

Write for us!

Got something to say? Something to review? News to discuss? Well we want to hear from you! Click here for more info

  • The F-Word Feeds
  • #
  • #