‘Bring on the Bond girls?’

// 18 May 2008

So, I am not a massive fan of the James Bond franchise. I understand this is not exactly a popular position, even with feminists. But, what can I say – we didn’t watch Bond films in my house growing up, so I don’t think I got the chance to get caught up in the fun of the explosions and suaveness before viewing them through a jaded, politically correct lense (I got my secret agent(ish) kicks from the Avengers instead).

Today the Observer’s review section includes a double pager on seven women’s views on 007. The online version doesn’t do justice to the degree to which the newspaper embraced this theme – dressing up the normally-a-bit-serious commentators of choice in black and giving them dodgy props, backed with a bit of silly art (Kate Kellaway’s grenade looks particularly weird).

So, I’m split on this one – I kind of like the idea, even if it is on the silly side. And I didn’t realise Bidisha had such impressive tattoos (including a full sleeve, which she apparently regrets, although I can’t see why myself).

And it fits with the tone of some of the opinions voiced – Kathryn Flett’s amusing piece on re-reading the first Bond novel, Casino Royale (“Despite being fairly baffled by the casino scenes (and there are a lot of casino scenes in Casino Royale – the clue is in the title) I was entirely in thrall to the heady adult glamour of it all”), steers clear of too serious a look – I am reliably informed that the book ends with the line: “The bitch is dead.”

But… many of the seven pieces include some quite serious criticism of the misogyny and racism in the ‘franchise’. As Bidisha puts it:

I think the Bond mythos is loved because it represents people’s biggest bigot fantasies: a lone, authoritative hetero who seems to have no friends, who likes neither women nor children, whose idea of human drama is simple violence and peril, whose job is a quest for a (preferably foreign) bogeyman.

So – isn’t it a bit off for the Observer to dress up serious critique of a significant cultural icon with some silly fun? And what’s the message by casting Bond’s critics as… Bond? Or are they meant to be Bond girls? Or a bit of both?! How does showing Kate Kellaway as a Bond Girl (if that’s what she’s meant to be, it’s all a bit unclear – perhaps someone who’s seen more of the films would be better able to judge) fit with her comment that:

I also have a problem with Bond girls. Nothing personal. It is just that I can’t stand them. Each woman is no more than a new gadget to Bond. They are glamorously disposable. They are drop-dead gorgeous and then, at least in the sense of their screen lives, they just drop dead. None of them has a chance of lasting, let alone mattering (they’re only women after all) while Bond persists in going on for ever.

Does this function to puncture serious criticism of Bond? Or is the photoshoot more of a subversive critique in its own right? I’m not sure.

Comments From You

Lisa // Posted 21 May 2008 at 1:55 pm

But some of the Bond Girls (I know should be ‘Women’) are better female role models than those in many other films. At least they have some strength, agility, character and active role in the story. Have you seen ‘Black Snake Moan’, ‘Hostel’ – in fact most of the rubbish in my local video store is worse than the average Bond film ?

Plus, Bond behaves better than many other male leads – again my local video store makes him almost likeable !

George // Posted 14 August 2008 at 11:52 pm

Lisa is right. All the following Bond films contain strong (good or bad, in some cases both) female characters:

– Goldfinger

– Thunderball

– On Her Majesty’s Secret Service

– The Spy Who Loved Me

– Moonraker

– For Your Eyes Only

– Octopussy

– Licence To Kill

– Goldeneye

– Tomorrow Never Dies

– The World Is Not Enough

– Die Another Day

And it seems like the newest one (Quantum Of Solace) will belong in that list too.

Have Your say

To comment, you must be registered with The F-Word. Not a member? Register. Already a member? Use the sign in button below

Sign in to the F-Word

Further Reading

Has The F-Word whet your appetite? Check out our Resources section, for listings of feminist blogs, campaigns, feminist networks in the UK, mailing lists, international and national websites and charities of interest.

Write for us!

Got something to say? Something to review? News to discuss? Well we want to hear from you! Click here for more info

  • The F-Word on Twitter
  • The F-Word on Facebook
  • Our XML Feeds