Bush does it again (force his views on others)

// 20 January 2009

The Blue Bird Film PosterI guess that’s the (ex)presidential privilege but it does strike me that declaring January 18th the Sanctity of Human Life Day smacks of desparation. The Press Release reads:

All human life is a gift from our Creator that is sacred, unique, and worthy of protection. On National Sanctity of Human Life Day, our country recognizes that each person, including every person waiting to be born, has a special place and purpose in this world. We also underscore our dedication to heeding this message of conscience by speaking up for the weak and voiceless among us.

Now ‘cuse me for being picky Mr Ex-President but that line “every person waiting to be born”. Now other than the gross fallacy in the film the Bluebird (a film which also involves by the way things like “Milk” and “Sugar” anthropomorphosised and talking) which depicted all people waiting patiently for a great mystical elevator to take them to be born that isn’t quite what happens. I guess Daddy (or Ex-President Bush Snr) was too busy to explain this to you but we don’t wait anywhere pre-birth, we are created in the moment when a sperm meets and egg and manages implantation. But we’re not persons at that point. Oh never mind, you know what, you find me the waiting room and I’ll arrange the nice angels in white coats to evaluate you…

But my bigger beef (fairy tales aside) is this – you claim every life is sacred but apparently that only applies to nice, white, US ones and not to the deaths your actions caused in Iraq and Afghanistan nor to the deaths of women caused by your misguided and frankly evil global gag rule which amounts to starve or deny contraception to women. Actually it doesn’t even apply to all nice, white lives either as workers rights and health carerights advocates would point out – just rich ones.

The next paragraph just breaks down hilariously:

“The most basic duty of government is to protect the life of the innocent.” – unless they are “foreign”, “poor” or non-white.

“My Administration has been committed to building a culture of life” by killing millions.

“America is a caring Nation” except when it’s raining hellfire down on your for being the “wrong type” of person (see above for examples).

I’ll stop before I get vitriolic but let me make my position clear – wherever you stand on abortion I don’t think we should allow Bush to hypocritcally present himself as the defender of anyone’s life – man, woman or child. Menstrual Poetry takes a more sanguine approach to this:

I really have to say, George Bush, you are a comedic genius. A president who has sent countless innocent men and women to death in a war that should publicly be acknowledged as the second Vietnam is not what I would call “protecting the innocent.” But we can read through the lines here; Bush opted for calling the day ‘Sanctity of Human Life Day’ instead of ‘Stop Having Abortions Day’ or ‘Let My Personal Morals Infringe Upon Yours Day’ or ‘Start Squeezing Out Future Dead Soldiers Day.’ I could really go on for hours about the hilarity of this day as well as how deceiving it’s clever title is, but I digress…Since January 18 is suddenly ‘Sanctity of Human Life Day’ I will be blogging…About birth control, emergency contraception, safe sex education, and yes, abortion.

Feministe also covers the story:

Cutting off health care to developing countries and pushing abstinence-until-marriage (even teenage marriage) has done wonders to affirm the lives of women and girls. His administration did absolutely nothing to prevent federal funding for abortion overseas — laws against federal funding of abortions abroad have been on the books for decades. What the Bush administration did do was remove health care funding from clinics that so much as mentioned abortion as an option — meaning that women and men around the world found their access to contraception, condoms, safer sex tools, HIV/AIDS treatment, sexual health information, well-baby care, pre-natal care, and STI care suddenly cut off. And they found themselves being told that the solution to HIV/AIDS is simply to hold off sex until marriage — despite the fact that for a lot of women, marriage is a major risk factor in contracting HIV (not to mention a potential risk for intimate partner violence and other abuses), and early marriage can mean early pregnancy, which can mean early death.

Women around the world need health care. They need basics, like access to clean water and nutritious food and safe housing. They don’t need sanctimonious “sanctity of life” days from leaders who have demonstrated again and again that women’s lives don’t matter, and that the “pro-life” commitment to life outside of the womb is virtually non-existant.

So, January 18th is Every Life if Sacred Day? Lets hope Ex-President Bush, you spent it reflecting on how saying “God made me do it” isn’t a good enough justification for hypocrisy. In the meantime, I’ll continue to see it as Winnie the Pooh day – at least he admits to being a bear of very little brain.

Comments From You

Shea // Posted 20 January 2009 at 6:41 pm

Right on Sister- I couldn’t have put it better myself.

“including every person waiting to be born”

Yes and George has done f*ck all to ensure their health and happiness in this world, but doing sweet FA to protect the environment and cut Co2 emissions to prevent run away global warming. I’m sure future generation will thank him.

Perhaps we have just misunderestimated him?!

JENNIFER DREW // Posted 20 January 2009 at 7:06 pm

Ah yes we can ignore Iraq, we can ignore Gaza, we can ignore Darfur, we can ignore what is happening in Mexico. Because the outgoing misogynist George Bush claims he holds all human life sacred. Ah but how does he define that phrase ‘human life’ – why it only applies to white, middle-class powerful men of course.

Women of all ethnicities, culture, etc. are non-human in Bush’s opinion. Only embryos and white powerful western males are human and it is only these categories which apparently matter. We can forget that once a child is born that child can be subjected to poverty, femicide if the child is female because the overriding factor is male control of women and certain other groups not deemed ‘white powerful males’ and human beings.

Chris // Posted 20 January 2009 at 10:01 pm

I just loved the article, it is well written even if there’s a little after taste of anger in it, but who am I to point out fingers when the sole mention of Bush’s deeds infuriate me. All in all, I’m glad you point out his lack of respect for life. History will name him as the plain killer he is, with so little respect to the lives of other people around the globe and so easy to discriminate among his own people.

Thankfully his legacy of hatred and murder is coming to an end. Thankfully.

Louise Livesey // Posted 21 January 2009 at 12:01 pm

Shea – my feeling is Bush is hard to underestimate, easy to overestimate – this is a man who choked on a pretzel….

Chris – sometimes we need to be angry, this is one of those sometimes.

Have Your say

To comment, you must be registered with The F-Word. Not a member? Register. Already a member? Use the sign in button below

Sign in to the F-Word

Further Reading

Has The F-Word whet your appetite? Check out our Resources section, for listings of feminist blogs, campaigns, feminist networks in the UK, mailing lists, international and national websites and charities of interest.

Write for us!

Got something to say? Something to review? News to discuss? Well we want to hear from you! Click here for more info

  • The F-Word on Twitter
  • The F-Word on Facebook
  • Our XML Feeds