[Don’t] shop an illegal

// 11 October 2011

Tags: , , , , ,

graffiti stencil of paddington bear and text reading immigration is not a crime

In a blatant attempt to divert attention from the disastrous NHS bill currently going through the Lords, David Cameron yesterday urged us all to shop an illegal immigrant. Not wealthy, well-educated immigrants, of course, just those who have the audacity to try and make a better life for themselves in a supposedly caring country. Exactly how we’re meant to spot illegal immigrants I don’t know, but I assume it will involve some kind of BNP-inspired check list steeped in prejudice, xenophobia and the kind of irrational fear embodied in Cameron’s promise that “Together we will reclaim our borders and send illegal immigrants home”.

So who are these people from whom we must wrench back our borders? Cameron paints a picture of scroungers determined to take advantage of our lax welfare state, creaming off our benefits while contributing nothing to society. He claims that those who are being persecuted will always be welcome in the UK, and that it is only these lazy scroungers the government wants to target. Yet in its attempt to keep out these so-called scroungers, the government works tirelessly to try and deport victims of rape and abuse back to countries where they face further violence and even death. In Sheffield alone we have at least half a dozen people in this situation. And as Flavia at Tiger Beatdown carefully documents in this post, the companies responsible for detaining and deporting these people are reported to perpetuate horrific human rights abuses, all to the tune of a mighty wad of cash. One of these companies, G4S, used to run Abu Ghraib.

This is what happens when you dehumanise people by making them “illegal”. Personally, I think we should be proud of the fact that people look to the UK as somewhere they can make a better life (though sadly this often isn’t the case), and I think we should be more than happy to help those who want to come here. People beyond our borders matter just as much as those within them, and framing immigrants who won’t automatically join the middle classes upon arrival as a drain on the economy and welfare system is just another way of blaming the poor for rampant inequality perpetuated by the rich.

If, once Mr Cameron has collected the billions of pounds worth of taxes stashed away in offshore accounts by 98 of our FTSE Top 100 companies, we still genuinely cannot afford to care for people born outside of the UK, then I might have some time for the argument being put forward. As things currently stand, encouraging the public to report people who don’t speak English very well and can’t recall the exact date of the Fire of London to Crimestoppers so they can be violently deported by a profit-driven corporation accused of “playing Russian roulette with detainees’ lives” is just disgusting.

Photo of graffiti stencil featuring Paddington Bear and the text “Imigration [sic] Is Not A Crime” by daveknapik, shared under a Creative Commons Licence.

Comments From You

Troika21 // Posted 12 October 2011 at 8:28 am

Its a tremendous compliment that a migrant pays to a host nation – your country is better than mine, and migration is good for a nation. After all, to get-up-and-go requires get-up-and-go, if you see what I mean.

Migrants can add alot to a nation who accepts them, however there are concerns that have to be addressed, which I think you rather gloss over. Migrants will add to the population in an area, and place more demand on services, and that money has to come from somewhere, simply saying that business should pay more tax is not addressing the underlying issue – if these are services that all of use use then we should all pay for them.

Are you seriously suggesting that people who enter this country illegally should be allowed to stay? Yes, there are potential mitigating circumstances, but economic migrants who come here without permission should be removed.

To say this is BNP inspired is not a serious claim, but it is not sensible stuff from the Tories either.

Have Your say

To comment, you must be registered with The F-Word. Not a member? Register. Already a member? Use the sign in button below

Sign in to the F-Word

Further Reading

Has The F-Word whet your appetite? Check out our Resources section, for listings of feminist blogs, campaigns, feminist networks in the UK, mailing lists, international and national websites and charities of interest.

Write for us!

Got something to say? Something to review? News to discuss? Well we want to hear from you! Click here for more info

  • The F-Word on Twitter
  • The F-Word on Facebook
  • Our XML Feeds